User loginNavigation |
Expressing usage constraints within the languageLet's suppose you have a language feature that only some code should have access to. For instance, Intensional Type Analysis/Reflection (ITA) can break abstraction barriers. Sometimes this sort of abstraction breaking is desirable, such as in generic pickling/serialization, printing, etc. but often it is not (violates parametricity theorems). However, if we expose ITA as a language construct, then there are no restrictions on its use. So what we want is controlled abstraction breaking. One solution is that ITA is exposed as a runtime provided object/module called Inspector. Inspector's signature has no constructor, so there is no way to construct an instance of it. Instead, an instance of Inspector is member of a standard set of such runtime objects that are provided to "main" and defines the "initial state of the world". "main" can then delegate access to Inspector to any code it deems should have it. This is a capability design. However, I'm wondering if there's some way to express this constraint within the language itself, instead of resorting to a design pattern. In other words, keep ITA as a language construct, but somehow be able to express when it is legal to use ITA. As an example of a possible solution, suppose we have a process language and two process constructors, one of which permits ITA expressions within it, the other of which doesn't: expr ::= process(expr) | lexpr | ita(expr) lexpr ::= confined(lexpr) | ... So a confined process cannot create an ordinary process or invoke ita. However, the composibility of the runtime Inspector object seems greater. Are there any other possibilities? By naasking at 2007-05-11 20:06 | LtU Forum | previous forum topic | next forum topic | other blogs | 5947 reads
|
Browse archives
Active forum topics |
Recent comments
27 weeks 2 days ago
27 weeks 2 days ago
27 weeks 2 days ago
49 weeks 3 days ago
1 year 1 week ago
1 year 3 weeks ago
1 year 3 weeks ago
1 year 5 weeks ago
1 year 10 weeks ago
1 year 10 weeks ago